The house at 75 1/2 Bedford Street has the advantage of being New York City's narrowest house, with a secret garden, lots of celebrity history?Cary Grant, John Barrymore, Edna St. Vincent Millay, and Margaret Mead are among those who've called the place home?and a tendency to reach for the stars when it comes to asking prices. The home sold for $2.175 million in early 2010, had a thorough renovation, and returned to market asking $4.3 million. Numerous PriceChops followed, taking the ask all the way down to $3.495 million in mid-2012. After a vacation from the market and a return at the same price, the property is now listed as in contract. We'll be very curious to see what it actually sells for.