Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a weekly column that explores what one can buy for a set dollar amount in various NYC neighborhoods. Is one man’s studio another man’s townhouse? Let’s find out! Today, we’re looking at apartments for sale for around $1.3 million.
A two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo in Carroll Gardens is asking $1.275 million, with monthlies coming in at a relatively low $498. The apartment has one large bedroom and one small one (currently used as a nursery), and there’s a good amount of storage space throughout. Bonus: It’s across the street from Lucali, the famed Brooklyn pizzeria.
Upper East Side
A three-bedroom co-op on the Upper East Side is listed for $1.295 million, though the maintenance comes in at a whopping $3,568/month. Two of those bedrooms are rather spacious, while the other could work as an office. There are also two bathrooms (including one that’s en-suite to the biggest bedroom), a huge living room, and a balcony. It’s located on East 86th Street close to Carl Schurz Park.
For just under $1.3 million, you could get an entire four-bedroom house on Staten Island that sits close to two of the borough’s many spacious parks. The more than 2,000-square-foot house could use some updates—its owners have lived there since the mid-’90s—but it has new kitchen appliances, lots of space, and a backyard. Cloves Lake and Silver Lake parks are both nearby.
A renovated one-bedroom co-op that sits at the nexus of the Flatiron District, Greenwich Village, and Union Square (it’s on Fifth Avenue and 14th Street) is going for $1.295 million, with maintenance at $2,015/month. There’s are plenty of closets, including one walk-in, and enough room in the open living room/kitchen area for a dining room table, among other things.
And finally, in Cobble Hill, a two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo is asking $1.345 million, with monthlies at $1,747. In addition to those two spacious bedrooms, there’s a smaller area used as an office just off the entryway; the kitchen isn’t the most modern, but it has a dishwasher and newish appliances. The apartment is located in a building on Tiffany Place, close to the Brooklyn waterfront.
Which NYC home would you choose for $1.3 million?
Carroll Gardens(191 votes)
Upper East Side(119 votes)
Staten Island(31 votes)
Union Square(207 votes)
Cobble Hill(99 votes)